Key Takeaways
Verdict: choose CPAP for severe apnea and consider an appliance for mild to moderate cases or if you can’t tolerate CPAP.
- CPAP lowers AHI more than an appliance.
- In trials, symptoms improved about equally in mild to moderate cases.
- People wore appliances longer each night.
- Skip store-bought versions as a substitute for diagnosis.
Verdict first: the cheaper-looking option isn’t always the better buy. Match it to your severity.
What the Trials Show
A 2024 randomized trial found people wore an oral splint 6.0 hours a night, against 5.3 hours with CPAP. CPAP still lowered the AHI more. CHOICE trial
Earlier work found health outcomes similar after a month. Phillips et al.
When CPAP Is the Better Buy
Severe apnea, with an AHI over 30, generally calls for CPAP. See small CPAP machines worth the money.

When an Appliance Makes Sense
Mild to moderate apnea, or CPAP you can’t tolerate. A custom device from a dentist trained in sleep medicine is the right kind.
Compare other budget options in CPAP alternatives and stop-snoring oral appliances.
Check That You Got Your Money’s Worth
Ask for a follow-up sleep study. Feeling better isn’t the same as a lower AHI.
